Australian Church
The Australian Church was an independent Christian church that was active in Australia between 1885 and 1957. It was founded by Charles Strong, a Scottish-born Presbyterian minister, after he resigned from the Presbyterian Church of Victoria while facing heresy charges. The church was politically and theologically liberal and advocated for pacifism, women's rights, and social reform. At its peak, the church's membership included many influential members of Melbourne's intellectual, political and business elite, including the future prime minister Alfred Deakin and the feminist Vida Goldstein.
The church's founder, Charles Strong, was educated at the University of Glasgow and was heavily influenced by the teachings of the liberal theologian John Caird. Strong moved to Australia to take up the position of minister at Scots Church, Melbourne, in 1875 and soon attracted suspicion from more conservative members of the Victorian Presbyterian clergy for his liberal views. He faced commissions of inquiry after writing a controversial essay on the doctrine of atonement and inviting Supreme Court Chief Justice George Higinbotham to deliver a lecture on the relationship between religion and science. Strong resigned from his position while his case was being heard before the Presbyterian Assembly in 1883. He founded the Australian Church soon after and constructed an opulent church building on Flinders Street for his approximately 1000-member congregation.
The church's theology was characterised by its rejection of sectarianism and rigid theological doctrine. Strong aspired to create a single national church, free of traditional dogmas, that would contribute to the development of an Australian "national sentiment". The church and its members founded a number of affiliated organisations to operate social welfare initiatives and to advocate for political causes, including pacifism, prison reform, and labour rights.
By the 1890s the church began to experience financial strain—in part due to the substantial mortgage it had taken out to construct its Flinders Street premises—which worsened during the First World War after many members left the church due to Strong's strident pacifism and increasingly radical preaching. In 1922 the church sold its premises on Flinders Street and moved to a smaller building. It continued to operate after Strong's death in 1942, but held its final service in 1955 and was formally wound up in 1957.
Background
Charles Strong, the founder of the Australian Church, was born in Scotland in 1844. He studied divinity at the University of Glasgow, where he became attracted to liberal theological currents. He was particularly influenced by the theologian John Caird, a leading figure in the philosophical movement known as British idealism. Strong was ordained in the Church of Scotland in 1868 and ministered in the coal mining town of Dalmellington, the town of Greenock, and the Glasgow suburb of Anderston, before being chosen as the new minister of Scots' Church, Melbourne, in 1875. He arrived in Australia in August of that year.Between 1875 and 1877, while Strong was known to hold progressive views, he did not provoke major opposition from the more conservative members of the Melbourne Presbyterian clergy. Strong was particularly successful in attracting the educated and disaffected back to religion, and was popular among Melbourne's working class. He served a term as moderator of the Melbourne Presbytery and was a member of the councils of Scotch College and Ormond College.
Following the publication of an anonymous 1877 pamphlet attacking unnamed figures within the Presbyterian church for apostasy, however, Strong's views began to attract greater criticism. In 1880 he published an essay on atonement in the Victorian Review. In the essay, he took a historical and rationalist approach to the doctrine of atonement, arguing that Christians should treat different theories of the atonement as "figures of speech...which are not to be pressed into exact logical definitions". The essay proved controversial and led to calls for Strong to be charged with heresy. His fellow Presbyterians were also concerned by his changes to the church's worship practices and by his calls to amend the Westminster Confession of Faith. In March 1881 a committee was appointed by the Presbytery to investigate Strong's article. In August he offered to resign from the church, but agreed to instead take six months of leave at the urging of congregants and church officials.
After his return, he stirred up renewed controversy by arguing that libraries and museums should be opened on Sundays. This was viewed as an important cause by many social liberals, who believed that it would allow the working classes to educate themselves, but was opposed by those who believed it would undermine the observance of the Sabbath. In 1883, he sparked further backlash by inviting the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Victoria, George Higinbotham, to deliver a lecture on the relationship between science and religion. Higinbotham argued that while religion and science were fundamentally compatible, religions must relinquish their "arbitrary dogmas" in order to keep up with modern science. The speech angered members of the church and led the Presbytery to appoint another committee of inquiry. Strong was threatened with heresy charges and offered his resignation from the Presbyterian church in August 1883. On 14 November, as the case was being heard before the Presbyterian Assembly, more than 2000 people farewelled Strong at the Melbourne Town Hall ahead of his planned departure from Australia. The next day, as Strong began his journey back to Scotland, the assembly revoked his status as a minister of the Presbyterian Church of Victoria.
History
Foundation
While Strong was offered ministry positions at various other Presbyterian churches during his time in Scotland, he had become disillusioned with the church. In October 1884 he returned to Melbourne and began to minister to an independent congregation of around 800 people at the Temperance Hall on Russell Street. During Strong's time overseas, a bill in the Victorian Parliament had unsuccessfully attempted to re-establish the independence of Scots Church from the Presbyterian Church of Victoria; after the bill's failure, a number of Strong's former congregants began to instead attend his services at the Temperance Hall. In November 1885 the Australian Church was officially founded; Strong was supported by an assistant minister, Francis Anderson, who led the church's evening services at the Melbourne Athenaeum. In materials distributed to the public, the church described itself as a "comprehensive Church, whose bond of union is the spiritual and the practical rather than creeds or ecclesiastical forms".Strong received financial support from George Higinbotham and from the future prime minister Alfred Deakin to construct a new church building. On 19 March 1887, the ceremony for the laying of the Australian Church's foundation stone was held with 2500 people in attendance. The new church, which could seat 1500 people, cost £21,000 to build and featured what was the largest organ in Australasia at the time.
Expansion
After founding the church, Strong promoted the establishment of affiliated congregations to advance his aim of growing the Australian Church into a national denomination. One of the more successful Australian Church affiliates was established by another former Presbyterian minister, Donald Fraser, in Newcastle in 1899. Fraser ministered to three congregations and reported over 1000 church attendees in 1899, but resigned in 1904, leaving the Newcastle congregations to wither away. A handful of other efforts to found Australian Church affiliates outside of Melbourne were made, including in Lucknow and Hyde Park, but with little success. By 1905, Strong's Melbourne church was the only Australian Church congregation remaining.Decline and dissolution
During the 1890s, Melbourne experienced an economic depression. Strong became increasingly radical in his politics and preached socialism in his sermons, advocating for land reform and economic redistribution. Strong's biographer Colin R. Badger writes that his increasing political radicalism, as opposed to his earlier religious liberalism, drove away many of the church's wealthy members and supporters. In 1894 the church had a deficit of £260 and struggled to afford repayments on the substantial loan it had taken out to pay for the construction of the church building.In the early 1900s the church began to experience even more serious financial strain. Many of the church's middle-class congregants had begun to move out to the suburbs, while others were driven away during the First World War by Strong's strident pacifism and anti-conscription activism. Two members of the church's committee resigned in 1916 after Strong refused to permit the singing of the national anthem at Sunday services, arguing that its "jingo and warlike attitude" was inappropriate for the setting. While the church received a temporary reprieve after a wealthy congregant left a bequest of £5000 in her will in 1913, by 1918 the financial situation of the church had once again become perilous. The church sold the building on Flinders Street in 1922 and moved to a smaller building on Russell Street with a significantly diminished congregation. After Strong's death in 1942, the church continued to operate for a time, with the former Methodist Mervyn Plumb serving as the church's minister between 1943 and 1950. The church held its final service and sold its building on Russell Street in 1955, before formally ceasing to operate in 1957. Its assets were used to found a research organisation, the Charles Strong Memorial Trust.
Activism and affiliated organisations
Social welfare
In 1885, soon after the church's establishment, the Social Improvement Society was founded to coordinate the church's charitable activities. In accordance with the church's anti-sectarian philosophy, the society welcomed members of any religious affiliation despite its connection to the Australian Church. The society issued educational literature and held lectures and sermons, many of which focused on the uplift of women as a means for broader improvements to social welfare.In 1886 the Social Improvement Society established Melbourne's first crèche in Collingwood to provide for the childcare needs of working women with young children. These efforts would eventually grow into the Melbourne Crèche Society, which opened four additional centres across Melbourne. In 1891 the society founded a Working Men's Club in Collingwood with support from Deakin and Higinbotham to allow working-class men to educate and improve themselves. The club hosted lectures, a debating club, and other educational programs. Strong and his wife Janet were also involved in the founding of a number of organisations that provided medical assistance to the poor, including the Convalescent Aid Society, the Melbourne District Nursing Society, and the Maternity Aid Society. In 1923 the Social Improvement Society convened a conference that led to the formation of the Association for Mentally Defective Children. Strong and other members from the Australian Church worked with the Victorian government to establish a boarding school in Travancore for children with disabilities.
In 1895, the Australian Church formed the Australasian Criminology Society, with the goal of engaging in the "study and promotion of the best methods for the treatment of criminals and the prevention of crime". The society advocated for the abolition of capital punishment, the introduction of rehabilitation programs modelled on New York's Elmira Reformatory, and the establishment of children's courts. Strong also formed a Melbourne branch of the Howard League for Penal Reform in 1922.