Taylor joined the Hull City academy at U9 level. He progressed through the club's academy setup and signed his first professional contract on 11 May 2022. Taylor was first included in the senior team squad on 15 April 2023, making the bench in the 0–0 draw away at Blackburn Rovers.
On 23 August 2024, Taylor and fellow-Hull academy player Jaedyn Chibanga joined Grimsby Borough on initial three-month loan deals. He remained with the club until the end of December 2024 and made a total of 19 appearances in all competitions during his time on loan.