Perry Lefko's negative review in Quill & Quire deemed that the book "reads like a long-winded essay or thesis from a hockey historian". Globe and Mail reviewer John Allemang noted that "erbal amateurism apart, it's enjoyable to catch traces of a more boyish, playful Stephen Harper". The Toronto Star review of the book also noted the academic style of the book but indicated the presentation of early 20th-century hockey provided a "historical perspective that has received scant attention among all the books devoted to hockey".