| Category | Honorees |
| Outstanding New Broadway Play |
|
| Outstanding New Broadway Musical | Jagged Little PillMoulin Rouge!Tina: The Tina Turner Musical |
| Outstanding New Off-Broadway Play | Cambodian Rock BandGreater ClementsHalfway Bitches Go Straight to HeavenMake BelieveSeared |
| Outstanding New Off-Broadway Musical | Darling GrenadineOctetThe Secret Life of BeesSoft PowerA Strange Loop |
| Outstanding Revival of a Play | BetrayalFires in the MirrorFor Colored Girls Who Have Considered Suicide/When the Rainbow is EnufFrankie and Johnny in the Clair de LuneA Soldier's Play |
| Outstanding Revival of a Musical | Little Shop of HorrorsThe Unsinkable Molly BrownWest Side Story |
| John Gassner Award | Catya McMullen, Georgia Mertching Is Dead Will Arbery, Heroes of the Fourth Turning Alexis Scheer, Our Dear Dead Drug Lord Eboni Booth, Paris |
| Outstanding Book of a Musical (Broadway or Off-Broadway) | Diablo Cody, Jagged Little Pill David Henry Hwang, Soft Power Michael R. Jackson, A Strange Loop Lynn Nottage, The Secret Life of Bees Mark Saltzman, Romeo and Bernadette |
| Outstanding New Score (Broadway or Off-Broadway) | Susan Birkenhead and Duncan Sheik, The Secret Life of Bees Ross Golan, The Wrong Man Michael R. Jackson, A Strange Loop Dave Malloy, Octet Jeanine Tesori and David Henry Hwang, Soft Power |
| Outstanding Director of Play | David Cromer, The Sound Inside Stephen Daldry, The Inheritance Kenny Leon, "A Soldier's Play" Jamie Lloyd, Betrayal John Ortiz, Halfway Bitches Go Straight to Heaven |
| Outstanding Director of a Musical | Stephen Brackett, A Strange Loop Michael Mayer, Little Shop of Horrors Diane Paulus, Jagged Little Pill Alex Timbers, Moulin Rouge! Ivo van Hove, West Side Story |
| Outstanding Choreography | Sidi Larbi Cherakoui, Jagged Little Pill Raja Feather Kelly, A Strange Loop Sonya Tayeh, Moulin Rouge! Anthony Van Laast, Tina: The Tina Turner Musical Travis Wall, The Wrong Man |
| Outstanding Orchestrations | Tom Kitt, Jagged Little Pill Alex Lacamoire, The Wrong Man Justin Levine, with Matt Stine, Katie Kresek, and Charlie Rosen, Moulin Rouge! Christopher Nightingale, A Christmas Carol Duncan Sheik and John Clancy, The Secret Life of Bees |
| Outstanding Actor in a Play | Ian Barford, Linda Vista Edmund Donovan, Greater Clements Raúl Esparza, Seared Tom Hiddleston, Betrayal Will Hochman, The Sound Inside Jonathan Pryce, The Height of the Storm |
| Outstanding Actress in a Play | Eileen Atkins,The Height of the Storm Judith Ivey, Greater Clements Joaquina Kalukango, Slave Play April Matthis, Toni Stone Mary-Louise Parker, The Sound Inside Portia, Stew |
| Outstanding Featured Actor in a Play | David Alan Grier, A Soldier's Play John Benjamin Hickey, The Inheritance Paul Hilton, The Inheritance Samuel H. Levine, The Inheritance Andrew Morrison, Blues for an Alabama Sky Chris Perfetti, Moscow Moscow Moscow Moscow Moscow Moscow |
| Outstanding Featured Actress in a Play | Liza Colón-Zayas, Halfway Bitches Go Straight to Heaven Montego Glover, All the Natalie Portmans Marsha Mason, Little Gem Krysta Rodriguez, Seared Lois Smith, The Inheritance Jennifer Van Dyck, The Confession of Lily Dare |
| Outstanding Actor in a Musical | Jonathan Groff, Little Shop of Horrors Joshua Henry, The Wrong Man Adam Kantor, Darling Grenadine Larry Owens, A Strange Loop Isaac Powell, West Side Story Aaron Tveit, Moulin Rouge! |
| Outstanding Actress in a Musical | Beth Malone, The Unsinkable Molly Brown Janelle McDermoth, We’re Gonna Die Karen Olivo, Moulin Rouge! Shereen Pimentel, West Side Story Elizabeth Stanley, Jagged Little Pill Adrienne Warren, Tina: The Tina Turner Musical |
| Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical | Christian Borle, Little Shop of Horrors Danny Burstein, Moulin Rouge! Gus Halper, Sing Street Jay Armstrong Johnson, Scotland, PA Francis Jue, Soft Power Daniel J. Watts, Tina: The Tina Turner Musical |
| Outstanding Featured Actress in a Musical | Eisa Davis, The Secret Life of Bees Kathryn Gallagher, Jagged Little Pill LaChanze, The Secret Life of Bees Judy McLane, Romeo & Bernadette Lauren Patten, Jagged Little Pill Saycon Sengbloh, The Secret Life of Bees |
| Outstanding Solo Performance | David Cale, We’re Only Alive For a Short Amount of Time Laura Linney, My Name Is Lucy Barton Aedin Moloney, Yes! Reflections of Molly Bloom Deirdre O’Connell, Dana H. Michael Benjamin Washington, Fires in the Mirror |
| Outstanding Scenic Design | Rob Howell, A Christmas Carol Tim Mackabee, Seared Derek McLane, Moulin Rouge! Clint Ramos, Grand Horizons Anthony Ward, The Height of the Storm |
| Outstanding Costume Design | Vanessa Leuck, Emojiland Jeff Mahshie, Bob & Carol & Ted & Alice Mark Thompson, Tina: The Tina Turner Musical Rachel Townsend & Jessica Jahn, The Confession of Lily Dare Catherine Zuber, Moulin Rouge! |
| Outstanding Lighting Design | Isabella Byrd, Heroes of the Fourth Turning Heather Gilbert, The Sound Inside Justin Townsend, Moulin Rouge! Hugh Vanstone, A Christmas Carol Hugh Vanstone, The Height of the Storm |
| Outstanding Projection Design | Luke Halls, West Side Story Brad Peterson, Broadway Bounty Hunter Lisa Renkel and Possible Productions, Emojiland Aaron Rhyne, The Sound Inside Hannah Wasileski, Fires in the Mirror |
| Outstanding Sound Design | Simon Baker, A Christmas Carol Mikhail Fiksel, Dana H. Peter Hylenski, Moulin Rouge! Lee Kinney and Sanae Yamada, Is This A Room Daniel Kluger, The Sound Inside |