| Category | Winner and nominees |
| Outstanding New Broadway Play | * The FerrymanWhat the Constitution Means to MeInkNetworkTo Kill a Mockingbird |
| Outstanding New Broadway Musical | * HadestownThe PromBe More ChillHead Over HeelsTootsie |
| Outstanding New Off-Broadway Play | * White NoiseFairviewThe House That Will Not StandLewiston/ClarkstonThe Light |
| Outstanding New Off-Broadway Musical | * Girl from the North CountryThe Beast in the JungleBlack LightThe Hello Girls |The Hello GirlsMidnight at the Never Get |
| Outstanding Revival of a Play | * All My SonsBy the Way, Meet Vera StarkThe Waverly GalleryJuno and the PaycockOur Lady of 121st Street |
| Outstanding Revival of a Musical | * Fiddler on the Roof (in Yiddish)Oklahoma!Smokey Joe's CafeCarmen JonesKiss Me, Kate |
| John Gassner Award | * Jeremy Kareken, David Murrell, and Gordon Farrell, The Lifespan of a FactDonja R. Love, Sugar in Our WoundsMing Peiffer, Usual GirlsCharly E. Simpson, Behind the SheetJeremy O. Harris, Slave Play |
| Outstanding Book of a Musical (Broadway or Off-Broadway) | * Robert Horn, Tootsie
The Hello Girls Anaïs Mitchell, Hadestown Jeff Whitty and James Magruder, Head Over Heels Conor McPherson, Girl from the North Country |
| Outstanding New Score (Broadway or Off-Broadway) | * Anaïs Mitchell, Hadestown Peter Mills, The Hello Girls David Yazbek, Tootsie Matthew Sklar, Chad Beguelin, The Prom Joe Iconis, Be More Chill |
| Outstanding Director of Play | * Sam Mendes, The Ferryman Bartlett Sher, To Kill a Mockingbird Jack O'Brien, All My Sons Rupert Goold, Ink Logan Vaughn, The Light |
| Outstanding Director of a Musical | * Rachel Chavkin, Hadestown Scott Ellis, Tootsie Daniel Fish, Oklahoma! Joel Grey, Fiddler on the Roof Cara Reichel, The Hello Girls |
| Outstanding Choreography | * Warren Carlyle, Kiss Me, Kate Denis Jones, Tootsie David Neumann, Hadestown Sergio Trujillo, Ain't Too Proud Christopher Gattelli, The Cher Show |
| Outstanding Orchestrations | * Daniel Kluger, Oklahoma! Michael Chorney, Todd Sickafoose, Hadestown Harold Wheeler, Ain't Too Proud Joseph Joubert, Carmen Jones Simon Hale, Girl from the North Country |
| Outstanding Actor in a Play | * Bryan Cranston, Network as Howard Beale Daveed Diggs, White Noise as Leo Bill Irwin, On Beckett Jeremy Pope, Choir Boy as Pharus Jonathan Young McKinley Belcher III, The Light as Rashad |
| Outstanding Actress in a Play | * Elaine May, The Waverly Gallery as Gladys Green Glenn Close, Mother of the Maid as Isabelle Arc Edie Falco, The True as Dorothea "Polly" Noonan Glenda Jackson, King Lear as Lear Mandi Masden, The Light as Genesis |
| Outstanding Featured Actor in a Play | * Benjamin Walker, All My Sons as Chris Keller John Procaccino, Downstairs as Gerry Bertie Carvel, Ink as Rupert Murdoch Hugh Dancy, Apologia as Peter/Simon John Clay III, Choir Boy as Anthony Justin "AJ" James |
| Outstanding Featured Actress in a Play | * Celia Keenan-Bolger, To Kill a Mockingbird as Scout Finch Stephanie Berry, Sugar in Our Wounds as Aunt Mama Harriett D. Foy, The House That Will Not Stand as Makeda Fionnula Flanagan, The Ferryman as Aunt Maggie Far Away Joan Allen, The Waverly Gallery as Ellen Fine |
| Outstanding Actor in a Musical | * Santino Fontana, Tootsie as Michael Dorsey / Dorothy Michaels Damon Daunno, Oklahoma! as Curly McLain Steven Skybell, Fiddler on the Roof as Tevye Reeve Carney, Hadestown as Orpheus Brooks Ashmanskas, The Prom as Barry Glickman |
| Outstanding Actress in a Musical | * Stephanie J. Block, The Cher Show as Star Kelli O'Hara, Kiss Me, Kate as Lilli Vanessi / Katharina Minola Beth Leavel, The Prom as Dee Dee Allen Anika Noni Rose, Carmen Jones as Carmen Jones Mare Winningham, Girl from the North Country as Elizabeth Laine |
| Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical | * André De Shields, Hadestown as Hermes George Salazar, Be More Chill as Michael / Michael Mell Ephraim Sykes, Ain't Too Proud as David Ruffin John Behlmann, Tootsie as Max Van Horn Reg Rogers, Tootsie as Ron Carlisle |
| Outstanding Featured Actress in a Musical | * Amber Gray, Hadestown as Persephone Leslie Kritzer, Beetlejuice as Delia/Miss Argentina Bonnie Milligan, Head Over Heels as Pamela Sarah Stiles, Tootsie as Sandy Lester Ali Stroker, Oklahoma! as Ado Annie Carnes |
| Outstanding Solo Performance | * Mike Birbiglia, Mike Birbiglia's The New One Jake Gyllenhaal, Sea Wall / A Life as Abe in A Life Maddie Corman, Accidentally Brave Renée Taylor, My Life On a Diet Carey Mulligan, Girls & Boys |
| Outstanding Scenic Design | * David Korins, Beetlejuice Bunny Christie, Ink Beowulf Boritt, Bernhardt/Hamlet Rachel Hauck, Hadestown Rob Howell, The Ferryman |
| Outstanding Costume Design | * Bob Mackie, The Cher Show Rob Howell, The Ferryman William Ivey Long, Tootsie William Ivey Long, Beetlejuice Arianne Phillips, Head Over Heels |
| Outstanding Lighting Design | * Bradley King, Hadestown Stacey Derosier, Lewiston/Clarkston Neil Austin, Ink Jason Lyons, Sugar in Our Wounds Peter Mumford, King Kong |
| Outstanding Projection Design | * Peter England, King Kong Tal Yarden, Network Jeff Sugg, All My Sons Peter Nigrini, Beetlejuice Alex Basco Koch, Be More Chill |
| Outstanding Sound Design | * Peter Hylenski, King Kong Eric Sleichim, Network Nevin Steinberg, Hadestown Jessica Paz, Hadestown Drew Levy, Oklahoma! John Gromada, All My Sons |