1960 American Football League draft
The 1960 American Football League draft was held on November 22–23, 1959, in Minneapolis, shortly after the organization of the league, and lasted 33 rounds. An additional draft of 20 rounds was held by the AFL on December 2.
Teams were required to fill the 11 squad positions by selecting four backs, two ends, two tackles, two guards, and a center with their first 11 picks. Before each position was selected, teams drew lots to determine the selection order. Though professional teams used dedicated offensive and defensive units, the league did not want to go 22 rounds before starting unrestricted drafting.
Territorial draft
To begin the draft, each of the eight teams were awarded a territorial or "bonus" selection to guarantee a local flavor that would boost the financial prospects of each franchise. These regional picks did not follow a specific order. Rather, they were mutually agreed upon by the other teams.| AFL team | Player | Position | College | Notes |
| Boston Patriots | Gerhard Schwedes | Halfback | Syracuse | |
| Buffalo Bills | Richie Lucas | Quarterback | Penn State | 1959 Maxwell Award winner. |
| Dallas Texans | Don Meredith | Quarterback | SMU | Did not sign. |
| Denver Broncos | Roger LeClerc | Center | Trinity | Did not sign. |
| Houston Oilers | Billy Cannon | Halfback | LSU | 1959 Heisman Trophy winner. |
| Los Angeles Chargers | Monty Stickles | End | Notre Dame | Did not sign. |
| New York Titans | George Izo | Quarterback | Notre Dame | Did not sign. |
| Minneapolis team | Dale Hackbart | Quarterback | Wisconsin | Did not sign. |
Source:
Regular draft
First selections
After the territorial picks, a consensus was reached on the top eight players at each position—at the time, college players were typically categorized by their offensive positions only. The names for each position were then placed in a hat and randomly drawn by each team. This process repeated until each franchise had made 33 selections, or three full offensive units. Those selections were considered as the first round of the draft.Boston Patriots
| Player | Position | College | Notes |
| Buddy Allen | Halfback | Utah State | Did not sign. |
| Ron Burton | Halfback | Northwestern | |
| Dale Chamberlain | Fullback | Miami | |
| Henry Christopher | End | SMU | |
| Dan Colchico | End | San Jose State | Did not sign. |
| Jack Cummings | Quarterback | NC State | |
| James Davis | Center | Oklahoma | |
| Foge Fazio | Center | Pittsburgh | Did not sign. |
| Max Fugler | Center | LSU | Did not sign. |
| Tim Gardner | Tackle | Duke | |
| James Goodyear | Tackle | Wake Forest | |
| Dave Harris | Halfback | Kansas | |
| Al Henderson | Tackle | Colorado State | |
| Jim Hickman | Tackle | Penn State | |
| Bob Kranz | Fullback | Penn State | |
| Joe Kulbacki | Halfback | Purdue | |
| Dee Mackey | End | East Texas State | Did not sign. |
| Leon Manley | Guard | West Texas State | |
| Cliff Manning | Tackle | Hardin–Simmons | |
| Pete Manning | End | Wake Forest | Did not sign. |
| Ed Mazurek | Tackle | Xavier | |
| Bill Meglen | Guard | Utah State | |
| Frank Mestnik | Fullback | Marquette | Did not sign. |
| Ron Mix | Tackle | USC | Rights traded to the Chargers. |
| Irv Nikolai | End | Stanford | |
| Jim Prestel | Tackle | Idaho | Did not sign. |
| Bob Salerno | Guard | Colorado | |
| Dick Soergel | Quarterback | Oklahoma State | |
| Larry Wagner | Tackle | Vanderbilt | |
| Harvey White | Quarterback | Clemson | |
| Tirey Wilemon | Halfback | SMU | |
| Gary Wisener | End | Baylor | Did not sign. |
Buffalo Bills
| Player | Position | College | Notes |
| Birtho Arnold | Tackle | Ohio State | |
| Charlie Bivins | Halfback | Morris Brown | Did not sign. |
| Don Black | End | New Mexico | |
| Bill Burrell | Guard | Illinois | Did not sign. |
| Paul Choquette | Fullback | Brown | |
| Mike Connelly | Center | Utah State | Did not sign. |
| Jim Conroy | Fullback | USC | Did not sign. |
| Bob Coogan | Tackle | Utah | |
| Lou Cordileone | Tackle | Clemson | Did not sign. |
| Ted Dean | Fullback | Wichita | Did not sign. |
| Willie Evans | Halfback | Buffalo | |
| Ross Fichtner | Quarterback | Purdue | Did not sign. |
| Jon Gilliam | Center | East Texas State | |
| Al Goldstein | End | North Carolina | Redrafted by the Raiders. |
| Jim Houston | End | Ohio State | Did not sign. |
| Ray Jauch | Halfback | Iowa | Did not sign. |
| Robert Khayat | Tackle | Ole Miss | Did not sign. |
| Ken Kirk | Center | Ole Miss | Did not sign. |
| Jim Leo | End | Cincinnati | Did not sign. |
| Chuck McMurtry† | Tackle | Whittier | |
| Bubba Meyer | End | TCU | |
| Ron Miller | End | Vanderbilt | |
| Gale Oliver | Tackle | Texas A&M | |
| Harold Olson† | Tackle | Clemson | |
| Ray Peterson | Halfback | West Virginia | |
| Vince Promuto | Guard | Holy Cross | Did not sign. |
| Rene Ramirez | Halfback | Texas | |
| Len Rohde | Tackle | Utah State | Did not sign. |
| Joe Schaffer | Tackle | Tennessee | |
| Wayne Schneider | Halfback | Colorado State | |
| Ivan Toncic | Quarterback | Pittsburgh | |
| Larry Wilson | Halfback | Utah | Did not sign. |
Dallas Texans
| Player | Position | College | Notes |
| Jack Atchason | End | Western Illinois | |
| George Boone | Tackle | Kentucky | |
| Chris Burford† | End | Stanford | |
| Earl Ray Butler | Tackle | North Carolina | |
| Gail Cogdill | End | Washington State | Did not sign. |
| Jim Crotty | Halfback | Notre Dame | Did not sign. |
| Gary Ferguson | Tackle | SMU | |
| Tom Glynn | Center | Boston College | |
| Gene Gossage | Tackle | Northwestern | Did not sign. |
| Jim Heineke | Tackle | Wisconsin | |
| William Jerry | Tackle | South Carolina | |
| John Kapele | Tackle | BYU | Did not sign. |
| Louis Kelley | Fullback | New Mexico State | |
| Gilmer Lewis | Tackle | Oklahoma | |
| John Malmberg | Tackle | Knox | |
| Arvie Martin | Center | TCU | |
| Tom Moore | Halfback | Vanderbilt | Did not sign. |
| Ola Lee Murchison | End | Pacific | |
| Bob Nelson | Center | Wisconsin | |
| Jim Norton† | End | Idaho | |
| Warren Rabb | Quarterback | LSU | Did not sign. |
| Howard Ringwood | Halfback | BYU | |
| Johnny Robinson | Halfback | LSU | |
| John Saunders | Fullback | South Carolina | |
| Glenn Shaw | Fullback | Kentucky | Did not sign. |
| Gordon Speer | Halfback | Rice | |
| Jack Stone | Guard | Oregon | |
| Marvin Terrell† | Guard | Ole Miss | |
| Emery Turner | Guard | Purdue | |
| Joe Vader | End | Kansas State | |
| Carroll Zaruba | Halfback | Nebraska |