George Burroughs
George Burroughs was a non-ordained Puritan preacher who was the only minister executed for witchcraft during the course of the Salem witch trials. He is remembered for reciting the Lord's Prayer flawlessly moments before his execution, something that was believed a witch could never do.
Early life and ministries
George Burroughs was born in Suffolk, England in 1652, although one source lists his birthplace as Virginia, while another claims he was born in Scituate in 1650.He was raised by his mother in the town of Roxbury, Massachusetts. In 1670, he completed his ministerial studies at Harvard College. In 1673, he married his first wife, Hannah Fisher; they had four children, three of whom survived.
Burroughs was described by author Frances Hill as "confident, strong-willed, and decisive, a man of action as well as a preacher, unusually athletic and clever enough to do well in Harvard. Short of stature, muscular, dark-complexioned, he was highly attractive to women, as is shown by his winning the hand of a rich widow as his second wife when he was a mere village minister."
In 1674, Burroughs served as pastor in the congregational church in Falmouth, Maine, until the town was destroyed by a Wabanaki raid in 1676. He and his family fled to Massachusetts and, after a series of moves, he became the minister of Salem Village in 1680. But he grew disillusioned with the community when they failed to pay his wages. When his wife Hannah died in childbirth in 1681, he resorted to borrowing money from community member John Putnam in order to cover her funeral expenses. Burroughs was unable to repay the debt, and resigned from his post, leaving Salem in 1683.
He obtained a ministry near Casco Bay in Maine, where he lived until 1688 when it too was subject to Indian attacks. He next moved to Wells, Maine, believing it would be safer. His second wife died in 1689, but he soon remarried to a woman named Mary, with whom he had a daughter.
Accusation and trial for witchcraft
On April 30, 1692, Thomas Putnam and Jonathan Walcott submitted a complaint against Burroughs "for sundry acts of witchcraft". The minister was arrested in Wells and brought to Salem Village on May 4.Among Burroughs' accusers were personal enemies from his former congregation who had sued him for debt. At his trial later in May, the evidence presented against him included his extraordinary feats of strength, such as lifting a musket by inserting his finger into the barrel. His failure to attend communion was also cited as proof of guilt. Moreover, he was suspected of killing his first two wives by witchcraft, and although clearly witchcraft was not involved, there is some historical evidence that he treated them poorly. During the trial, Cotton Mather, a minister from Boston, said that Burroughs "had been famous for the barbarous use of his two late wives, all the country over"; and a girl accuser described a nightmarish vision she had in which "she stared into the blood-red faces of his dead wives."
Suspicion of being a secret Baptist
Burroughs was also suspected of being a crypto-Baptist because he failed to baptize his younger children. He admitted during cross-examination that on multiple occasions he had failed to take the sacrament at Sabbath services, and that only his eldest child was baptized. These acts of religious non-conformity may have contributed to the hostility expressed towards him by Mather and other Congregational Church leaders.Execution and aftermath
Although the jury had discovered no witches' marks on his body, George Burroughs was nonetheless found guilty of witchcraft, and of conspiring with the Devil. Before a record number of spectators, he was hanged on Proctor's Ledge at Gallows Hill in Salem on August 19, 1692. He was the only minister to suffer this fate during New England's witchcraft hysteria.While standing on a ladder before the crowd, waiting to be hanged, Burroughs movingly recited the Lord's Prayer without making a single mistake, something generally considered by the Court of Oyer and Terminer to be impossible for a witch to do. This feat stirred misgivings among the spectators. After the hanging, Cotton Mather from atop his horse sought to smother any sparks of discontent by reminding everyone that Burroughs had never been ordained, and that he was convicted in a court of law. Mather spoke convincingly enough that four more executions took place.
Below is the original account of the hanging as compiled and published in 1700 by Robert Calef in , and later reprinted or relied upon by others including Charles Wentworth Upham and George Lincoln Burr:
Later, the government of the Massachusetts colony recognized Burroughs' innocence and awarded 50 pounds damages to his widow and children, though this led to disputes over the division of the award among his heirs. The musket reportedly used for demonstration purposes at the trial was for a time located at Fryeburg Academy in Fryeburg, Maine, having been taken there in 1808 for display in the Academy museum; but it was said to have been destroyed in the Academy fire of 1850.