Vallabha
Vallabha, also known as Vallabhācārya or Vallabha Dīkṣita, was the founder of the Kr̥ṣṇa-centered Puṣṭimārga sect of Vaishnavism, and propounded the philosophy of Śuddhādvaita.
His biography is depicted in several sectarian Puṣṭimārga hagiographies. Born into a Telugu Brahmin family, Vallabha studied Hindu philosophy from early age, then traveled throughout the Indian subcontinent, particularly the Braj region, for over 20 years. He became one of the important leaders of the devotional Bhakti movement. He won many philosophical scholarly debates against the followers of Advaita Vedānta. He began the institutional worship of Śrī Nāthajī on Govardhana Hill. He acquired many followers in the Gangetic plain and Gujarat. After his death, the leadership of his sampradāya passed to his elder son Gopīnātha.
Vallabha's philosophy promoted the householder lifestyle over asceticism, suggesting that through loving devotion to the deity Kr̥ṣṇa, any householder could achieve salvation. He authored many texts including but not limited to, the Aṇubhāṣya, Ṣoḍaśa Grantha or sixteen tracts and several commentaries on the ''Bhāgavata Purāṇa.''
Life
Childhood
According to tradition, Vallabha's family were Velanāṭa or Vellanāḍu Telugu Brahmins who belonged to the Bhāradvāja gotra and the Taittirīya branch of the Yajurveda. Their ancestral village was Kāṅkaravāḍa on the southern bank of the Godāvarī River. Keśvararāma Kāśīrāma Śāstrī identifies the village of Kāṁkara with Kāṁkarapāṁḍhu or Kāṁkaravāḍa.According to some sources such as the Śrīvallabhadigvijaya, Vallabha's birth occurred in the forests of Campāraṇya, due to his parents fleeing Vārāṇasī in fear of Muslim invasion. These sources depict his birth as miraculous, with his parents initially leaving the seemingly still-born infant beneath a śamī tree, before being recalled by a supernatural voice to see Vallabha alive and surrounded by fire. According to other hagiographies such as Śrī Nāthajī Prākaṭya kī Vārtā, Vallabha appeared in the Agnikuṇḍ in Mathurā.
Most hagiographies date Vallabha's birth to Vaiśākha vada 11, 1535 V.S.. Though conversion of this date into the Gregorian calendar is disputed among scholars, Hawley confirms the year 1478 after adjusting for the calendar used in Braj. The followers of Gokulanātha, one of Vallabha's grandsons, consider Vallabha's year of birth to be 1473 CE. G.H. Bhatt, on comparing the two dates, states that the year 1473 CE is correct. In his view, the sources mentioning 1473 CE are older and more authentic than those mentioning 1478 CE.
Soon after Vallabha's birth his family moved back to Vārāṇasī. His education consisted of learning Sanskrit texts such as the Upaniṣads, Vedas, and Purāṇas.
According to the Śrī Govardhananāthajī ke Prākaṭya kī Vārtā, Mādhavendra Purī taught Vallabha in Varanasi, however this is considered "highly improbable" by Entwistle due to the dates of Vallabha's birth and Mādhavendra's death. When asked what he would like as a fee for teaching Vallabha, Mādhavendra asked to serve Śrī Nāthajī, as he had a premonition that Vallabha would establish the formal worship of the deity. When Mādhavendra Purī arrived at Govardhan Hill, the image was being already being worshipped as a snake deity by the local villagers, and as Kr̥ṣṇa by Saddu Pāṇḍe. Mādhavendra Purī adorned Śrī Nāthajī with a garland and turban decoration, and offered him milk. The text also claims that Mādhavendra was appointed mukhiyā of the Bengali priests, which is also considered unlikely by Entwistle since the Śrī Nāthajī temple was built after his lifetime. Mādhavendra Purī later went to South India to get sandalwood, from which he never returned. Other Puṣṭimārga texts and texts othe Gauḍīya Vaiṣṇava tradition posit contrasting narratives surrounding the identity of Mādhavendra Puri's students and the establishment of the Kr̥ṣṇa image on Govardhana Hill.
First pilgrimage
Nearing the end of his life, Lakṣmaṇa Bhaṭṭa decided to take his wife and 10-year-old son along on a pilgrimage to southern India. They first stopped at the Vaishnava temple of Jagannātha in Purī in 1489. The local ruler was sponsoring a great philosophical debate where four questions were posed to scholars: "What is the foremost scripture? Who is the foremost deity? Which is the most effective mantra? What is the easiest and best action?", to which Vallabha responded with the Bhagavad Gītā, Kr̥ṣṇa, any of Kr̥ṣṇa's names, and sevā to Kr̥ṣṇa, whereupon Jagannātha wrote a śloka in support of his response and condemning the supporters of Advaita Vedānta.In 1490, they reached the temple of Veṅkaṭeśvara at Tirupati, where Lakṣmaṇa Bhaṭṭa died, and Illammāgārū began to live with her brother in Vijayanagara.
Grand victory at Vijayanagara
When Vallabha was living in his ancestral village of Kāṅkaravāḍa, he heard of a philosophical debate being held in at the court of King Kr̥ṣṇadevarāya of Vijayanagara, and that the Vaiṣṇava schools of thought were being beaten by Advaita Vedānta philosophers. Vallabha immediately went to Vijayanagara to join the debate, and entered the Vaiṣṇava camp led by Vyāsatīrtha of the Mādhva school. Vallabha through his erudition and debate skills defeated the Advaita philosophers, and was rewarded by Kr̥ṣṇadevarāya with large amounts of gold.Vallabha was also offered the prestigious title of ācārya from the Mādhva sampradāya and the Viṣṇusvāmī sampradāya. Vallabha chose to become ācārya of the Viṣṇusvāmī school. Very little is known of the Viṣṇusvāmī school, and by Vallabha's time its followers were few. The majority view among sectarian followers is that Vallabha chose to become ācārya of that school in order to make his own doctrines more prestigious, and that there is likely no real connection between the ideas of Viṣṇusvāmī and Vallabha. A minority of followers believe there is a connection between the philosophies of Viṣṇusvāmī and Vallabha. Modern scholars hold there is no legitimate connection between the two philosophies. According to Keśvararāma Kāśīrāma Śāstrī, Vallabha himself did not claim to belong to Viṣṇusvāmī's school. He notes that in the Subodhini, Vallabha claims Viṣṇusvāmī's devotional path belongs to the tamāsa guṇa, while his own is nirguṇa. Only later writers such as Gosvāmī Puruṣottama, Yogī Gopeśvara, and Gadādharadāsa link Vallabha's and Lakṣmaṇa Bhaṭṭa's philosophical school to Viṣṇusvāmī. It is also stated in traditional biographies that Bilavamaṁgala waited 700 years for Vallabha to take his seat. Rather Vallabha himself states that despite Bilvamaṁgala's Māyāvāda tendencies, through his devotion he can achieve mokṣa.
According to sectarian literature, this debate occurred shortly after Lakṣmaṇa Bhaṭṭa's death in 1490 when Vallabha was only 13 years old; however, Kr̥ṣṇadevarāya only became king of Vijayanagara in 1509.
The debate is mentioned in the Caurāsī Baiṭhak Caritra and but is not found in independent historical sources. According to Saha, the Vijayanagara episode is meant to portray "the image of a victorious Vallabha winning the subcontinent for Kr̥ṣṇa". It is also mentioned in the Sampradāya-Pradīpa, whose narrative is described as "clearly counterfactual" by Hawley who posits the episode was written for the purpose of furthering the interests of the Puṣṭimārga in the late 17th century.
Reception of the Brahmasambandha mantra and installation of Śrī Nāthajī
In 1493, Vallabha is said to have had a dream where Kr̥ṣṇa ordered him to go to Govardhana Hill and establish proper service to his image that had appeared there years ago. When he arrived in Gokula in 1494, Vallabha had a vision where Kr̥ṣṇa appeared before him and bestowed upon him the Brahmasambandha mantra, which was to be used to clean the flaws of a human soul. The next morning, Vallabha administered the mantra to his companion Dāmodaradāsa Harasānī, who became the first member of the Puṣṭimārga. Most sources state these events occurred in Gokula, except the Śrī Nāthajī Prākaṭya kī Vārtā which states it happened in Jharkhand.When Vallabha came to Govardhana Hill, he went to the house of Saḍḍu Pāṇḍe. Saḍḍu Pāṇḍe had received a vision from Kr̥ṣṇa years earlier that told him a stone that had appeared on Govardhana Hill was his own svarūpa and that he should give offerings to it. The image was known as Devadamana; Vallabha announced that it was actually the svarupa of Śrī Govardhananāthajī and initiated an ascetic named Rāmdās Chauhān to perform the regular worship. In 1499 a wealthy merchant from Ambālā named Pūrṇamalla Khatrī began building a temple for Srī Nāthajī.
Personal life
Vallabha may have intended to remain a lifelong celibate brahmacārī, but during his second pilgrimage of India between 1501 and 1503, he had gone to Paṁḍḥarapura to view the god Viṭṭhala or Viṭhobā. There Vallabha was ordered by Viṭṭhala to marry. Some sectarian sources assert this was because Viṭṭhala wanted to take birth as his son, and others say it was to create a line of descendants to preserve and promote Vallabha's version of bhakti-mārga. This episode is mentioned in the Vallabhākhyāna, Nija Vārtā, and Sampradāya Kalpadruma and according to Entwistle is a later myth.Following his caste traditions and practices, Vallabha married Mahālakṣmī sometime between 1502 and 1504, a Vārāṇasī girl of his own caste who began living with him upon maturity c. 1510–1512. Vallabha had two houses, one at Aṛaila on the Yamunā river across Prayāgarāja, and at Caranāṭa near Vārāṇasī. According to Saha, the location of his home provided a central location which allowed him to access to preach and convert throughout northern and central India.
His first son, Gopīnātha, was born in 1512 at Aṛaila and according to sectarian tradition was the avatāra of Balarāma, elder brother of Kr̥ṣṇa. His second son, Viṭṭhalanātha, was born in 1515 at Caranāṭa, and is considered the avatar of Viṭṭhala.
Pilgrimages and preaching tours of India
Vallabha made three pilgrimages throughout India which are documented in later sectarian sources. These pilgrimages are stated to have taken place between 1479 and 1530, although Saha doubts the accuracy of the dates. At pilgrimage sites such as Dvārakā, Kannauja, Purī, Mathurā, Gokula, and Govardhana, Vallabha had theological debates and attracted followers and devotees. He made extensive conversion campaigns in the Gangetic Plain and Gujarat, where he attracted converts from various castes including Bhumihars, Rajputs, Gurjars, Ahirs, Kurmis, and Vaniyas, Bhatias, Kanbis, and Patidars respectively. In the Caurāsī Vaiṣṇavan kī Vārtā, the lives of eighty-four of Vallabha's most notable devotees are narrated. Of the 84 devotees, 39 were Brahmins, 36 were mercantile or landowning Kshatriyas, 5 were Vaishyas, and 6 were Shudras.Only scholarly theory for why Vallabha's theology was attractive to these groups was that of social mobility. For agrarian castes, particularly in Gujarat, the emphasis on purity gave higher status. For mercantile castes, purity as well as the emphasis on restraint and frugality in daily life elevated their status, while wealth could then be funnelled toward religiously meritorious sevā to Kr̥ṣṇa.
Another reason was that Vallabha promoted a househoulder life-affirming, socially conservative view that appealed to castes that depended on social and political stability for their livelihoods, notably in the context of splintering Muslim sultanates in India.
Death
In 1530, Vallabha took a vow of renunciation and withdrew to the banks on the Gaṅgā river in Vārāṇasī. After a month, he summoned his sons Gopīnātha and Viṭṭhalanatha, and designated the 18 or 19 year old Gopīnātha as his successor. According to sectarian accounts, he walked in the Gaṅgā and vanished in a flash of light. This event is said to have occurred on Āṣāḍha suda 3, 1587 V.S..Works
Vallabha composed several texts during his lifetime most notable of which are:Aṇubhāṣya, a partial commentary on the Brahma Sūtra-s up to III.23Subodhini, a partial commentary on the Bhāgavata Purāṇa Tattvārthadīpanibandha, a text interpreting existing Hindu scriptures through Vallabha's philosophy of ŚuddhādvaitaTattvārthadīpanibandhaprakāśa, a partial commentary on the Tattvārthadīpanibandha Ṣoḍaśagrantha, sixteen treatises on important facets of Śuddhādvaita and theology of the PuṣṭimārgaThere are also other texts attributed to Vallabha some of which are considered to be either lost or not actually composed by him. These includes Jaiminīyasūtrabhāṣya, Pātrāvalambanam, Śrīpuruṣottamanāmasahasram, Trividhanāmāvalī, Premāmr̥tam, Parivr̥ddhāṣṭakam, and Madhurāṣṭakam. Smith notes that it is possible for Vallabha's work to have been lost in the first twenty years after his death, as his family became embroiled in disputes until Viṭṭhalanātha's final accession as head of the family and sect after the deaths of Gopīnātha and his son Puruṣottama.
''Aṇubhāṣya''
In the Aṇubhāṣya Vallabha provides formal philosophical proof for Śuddhādvaita; the text is highly intellectual in nature. Vallabha argues that the jīva is inseparable from akṣarabrahman yet dependent on God's grace. He argues that jīvas due to their svabhāva and adhikāri are either attracted to the religious path of knowledge or of devotion. He states the fruit of knowledge is mokṣa, union with an abstract, absolute, impersonal akṣarabrahman. In contrast, the higher fruit of devotion is entrance into nityalīlā, which is the state of observing and participating in God's spontaneous and creative nature.''Tattvārthadīpanibandha''
This text is divided into three sections: Śāstrārtha, Sarvanirṇaya, and Bhāgavatārtha. In the Śāstrārthaprakaraṇa, Vallabha gives his view on the contents of the Bhagavad Gītā, which he considers to be highest śāstra due to it embodying the words of Kr̥ṣṇa. He discusses various topics including the nature of the universe and God and argues that bhakti is based on knowledge of Kr̥ṣṇa as depicted in the Bhagavad Gītā and Bhāgavata Purāṇa. In the Sarvanirṇayaprakaraṇa, Vallabha surveys the philosophies of rival schools and asserts the superiority of his own views on devotion and the nature of souls to the universe. In the Bhāgavatārthaprakaraṇa, Vallabha gives his view on the Bhāgavata Purāṇa as an entire text, its skandhas, prakaraṇas, and adhyāyas.''Subhodinī''
This commentary on the Bhāgavata Purāṇa is Vallabha's most esoteric work, and provides commentary on the text at a deeper level than the Bhāgavatārthaprakaraṇa down to the vākya, pada, and akṣara. In this text Vallabha uses Alaṃkāraśāstra to analyze devotional experiences.''Śoḍaśagrantha''
This text has 16 short treatises.- Yamunāṣṭakam: esoteric hymn to the river goddess Yamunā which is recited daily by followers
- Bālabodha: explains the puruṣārtha according to rival schools of thought
- Siddhāntamuktāvalī: explains the value of Kr̥ṣṇa sevā on the terrestrial, spiritual, and celestial planes as well as different types of worship depending on an individual's ability
- Puṣṭipravāhamaryādābheda: describes the three types of jīvas: puṣṭi, maryādā, and pravāha
- Siddhāntarahasya: Vallabha's account of Kr̥ṣṇa's instructions to him on Brahmasambandha
- Navaratna: a hymn in which Vallabha urges devotees to shun distresses as they distract from Kr̥ṣṇa sevā and to treat them as a part of līlā
- Antaḥkaraṇaprabodha: Vallabha urges his own heart to be free of worry and have singleminded devotion to Kr̥ṣṇa
- Vivekadhairyāśraya: summarizes Vallabha's views on discrimination, patience, and divine refuge
- Catuḥślokī: four verse hymn that explains the puruṣārtha as devotional acts appropriate to the Puṣṭimārga
- Śrīkr̥ṣṇāśraya: explains why Kr̥ṣṇa should be the sole refuge for devotees, why he is superior to other deities, and why devotion to him is the only salvation from Kali Yuga, which it also describes
- Bhaktivardhinī: explains the how devotion silently increases through various stages and explains the different qualities of lifestyles with respect to devotion
- Jalabhedha: classifies the 20 kinds of devotees who differ based on bhāva and spiritual capabilities by using water as an analogy
- Pañcapadyāni: classifies the different kind of listeners to Kr̥ṣṇa's stories and praises
- Saṃnyāsanirṇayaḥ: Vallabha explains the conditions for renunciation of worldly life and how renunciates dedicated to bhakti differ from those dedicated to jñāna
- Nirodhalakṣaṇa: describes the concept of nirodha, living disengagement from wordly life and single minded dedication to Kr̥ṣṇa, which Vallabha states he has achieved
- Sevāphalam: describes the rewards of Kr̥ṣṇa devotion, with a description of the otherworldly gifts that allow love of Kr̥ṣṇa to flourish in a graced mortal body
Philosophy
Vallabha formulated the philosophy of Śuddhādvaita, in response to Śaṅkara's Ādvaita Vedānta, which he called Maryādā Mārga or Path of Limitations. Vallabha asserted that religious disciplines focusing on Vedic sacrifices, temple rituals, puja, meditation, and yoga held limited value. Additionally Vallabha rejected the concept of Māyā, stating that the world was a manifestation of the Supreme Absolute and could neither be tainted nor change. The school rejects the ascetic lifestyle and cherishes householder lifestyle, wherein followers see themselves as participants and companions of Kr̥ṣṇa, viewing their daily lives as an ongoing ''raslila.''Brahman
According to Vallabha, Brahman consists of existence, consciousness, and bliss, and when manifested completely, as Kr̥ṣṇa himself. The purpose of this tradition is to perform sevā out of love for Kr̥ṣṇa. According to Vallabha, through single minded religiosity, a devotee would achieve awareness that there is nothing in the world that is not Kr̥ṣṇa.Puṣṭi
According to Vallabha there are three kinds of souls: puṣṭi, maryāda, and pravāha. The puṣṭi and maryāda souls are divine souls that have potential of upliftment or salvation. The puṣṭi souls rely on Kr̥ṣṇa's grace as the sole effective means to achieve devotion, and other efforts are insignificant without God's grace.Vallabha distinguishes between two aspects of devotion: the maryāda and the puṣṭi. Maryāda followers rely on their actions and God's judgment for spiritual rewards, aligning with scriptural injunctions. In contrast, Puṣṭi followers rely solely on God's grace, prioritizing complete devotion and surrender without personal effort, embodying unconditional love and faith towards God. Vallabha also emphasizes that the path of pusti is open to all, regardless of caste or gender. He cautions against seeing this path as too focused on pleasure, saying it is about pure, divine devotion without being attached to worldly desires.