Purva paksha


Pūrva paksha, sometimes also transliterated as Poorva paksha, literally means former view/position. It is a tradition in the debates of Indian Logicians. It involves building a deep familiarity with the opponent's point of view before criticising it, similar to the modern day device of steelmanning. The purva paksha approach has been used by Adi Shankaracharya as well as Ramanuja and later acharyas in their works.
In ancient Indian jurisprudence, purva paksha referred to the complaint, with other parts of a trial consisting of the uttar, the kriyaa, and the nirnaya.
In his book Being Different, Rajiv Malhotra sought to use the purva paksha approach. Malhotra states that purva paksha
According to Shrinivas Tilak, Malhotra's use of purva paksha in Being Different may be regarded as a kind of "reverse anthropology." Tilak states that