History of atomic theory
Atomic theory is the scientific theory that matter is composed of particles called atoms. The definition of the word "atom" has changed over the years in response to scientific discoveries. Initially, it referred to a hypothetical fundamental particle of matter, too small to be seen by the naked eye, that could not be divided. Then the definition was refined to being the basic particles of the chemical elements, when chemists observed that elements seemed to combine with each other in ratios of small whole numbers. Then physicists discovered that these atoms had an internal structure of their own and therefore could be divided after all.
Atomic theory is one of the most important scientific developments in history, crucial to all the physical sciences. At the start of The Feynman Lectures on Physics, physicist and Nobel laureate Richard Feynman offers the atomic hypothesis as the single most prolific scientific concept.
Philosophical atomism
The basic idea that matter is made up of tiny indivisible particles is an old idea that appeared in many ancient cultures. The word "atom" comes from the Greek word "atomos", meaning "indivisible". These ancient ideas were based in philosophical reasoning rather than scientific reasoning. Modern atomic theory is not based on these old concepts.Pre-atomic chemistry
Working in the late 17th century, Robert Boyle developed the concept of a chemical element as substance different from a compound.Near the end of the 18th century, a number of important developments in chemistry emerged without referring to the notion of an atomic theory. The first was Antoine Lavoisier who showed that compounds consist of elements in constant proportion, redefining an element as a substance which scientists could not decompose into simpler substances by experimentation. This brought an end to the ancient idea of the elements of matter being fire, earth, air, and water, which had no experimental support. Lavoisier showed that water can be decomposed into hydrogen and oxygen, which in turn he could not decompose into anything simpler, thereby proving these are elements. Lavoisier also defined the law of conservation of mass, which states that in a chemical reaction, matter does not appear nor disappear into thin air; the total mass remains the same even if the substances involved were transformed. In 1797 the French chemist Joseph Proust established the law of definite proportions, which states that if a compound is broken down into its constituent chemical elements, then the masses of those constituents will always have the same proportions by weight, regardless of the quantity or source of the original compound. This definition distinguished compounds from mixtures.
Dalton's chemical atomism
In 1804 John Dalton studied data gathered by himself and by other scientists and noticed a pattern that later came to be known as the law of multiple proportions: in compounds which contain two particular elements, the amount of Element A per measure of Element B will differ across these compounds by ratios of small whole numbers. For instance, Dalton investigated three oxides of nitrogen: "nitrous oxide", "nitrous gas", and "nitric acid". These compounds are known today as nitrous oxide, nitric oxide, and nitrogen dioxide respectively. "Nitrous oxide" is 63.3% nitrogen and 36.7% oxygen, which means it has 80 g of oxygen for every 140 g of nitrogen. "Nitrous gas" is 44.05% nitrogen and 55.95% oxygen, which means there are 160 g of oxygen for every 140 g of nitrogen. "Nitric acid" is 29.5% nitrogen and 70.5% oxygen, which means it has 320 g of oxygen for every 140 g of nitrogen. 80, 160, and 320 form a ratio of 1:2:4.John Dalton saw this as evidence that the chemical elements combine with each other by basic units of weight. The basic units were indivisible as far as he could tell, so he concluded he had discovered the atoms that chemists and philosophers had long hypothesized. Given a ratio of 1:2:4, Dalton deduced that the formulas for the oxides of nitrogen are N2O, NO, and NO2.
In 1804, Dalton explained his atomic theory to his friend and fellow chemist Thomas Thomson, who published the first full explanation in his book A System of Chemistry in 1807. Dalton's own version appeared in 1808 under the title A New System of Chemical Philosophy and adopted with word atom to refer to objects he previous called ultimate particles. This new chemical atomic theory proposed atoms with scientific properties: all atoms of an element have the same weight; atoms of different elements have different weights. No atoms are created or destroyed in chemical reactions. Dalton was able to use his concept of atoms to reproduce the then known laws of chemistry.
Dalton defined an atom as being the "ultimate particle" of a chemical substance, and he used the term "compound atom" to refer to "ultimate particles" which contain two or more elements. This is inconsistent with the modern definition, wherein an atom is the basic particle of a chemical element and a molecule is an agglomeration of atoms. The term "compound atom" was confusing to some of Dalton's contemporaries as the word "atom" implies indivisibility, but he responded that if a carbon dioxide "atom" is divided, it ceases to be carbon dioxide. The carbon dioxide "atom" is indivisible in the sense that it cannot be divided into smaller carbon dioxide particles.
Dalton's system was based on relative weights. By his measurements, 7 grams of oxygen will combine with 1 gram of hydrogen to make 8 grams of water. Dalton considered water to be a "binary atom", with one oxygen atom and one hydrogen atom, HO. He also considered hydrogen gas to be elemental, given a atomic weight of 1. Thus the 1:7 measured ratio means oxygen gets an atomic weight of 7 in Dalton's system. However, if Dalton had analyzed hydrogen peroxide,, instead of water he would have assigned oxygen an atomic weight of 16. Thus Dalton's relative weight system was fundamentally insufficient to determine unambiguous atomic weight or chemical structures.
Some of the problems in Dalton's method were corrected by Joseph-Louis Gay-Lussac and Amedeo Avogadro. They developed ratio laws for gases similar to the laws developed for chemicals by Proust and Dalton. In 1811, Avogadro proposed that equal volumes of any two gases, at equal temperature and pressure, contain equal numbers of molecules. Avogadro's hypothesis, now usually called Avogadro's law, provided a method for deducing the relative weights of the molecules of gaseous elements, for if the hypothesis is correct relative gas densities directly indicate the relative weights of the particles that compose the gases. This way of thinking led directly to a second hypothesis: the particles of certain elemental gases were pairs of atoms, and when reacting chemically these molecules often split in two. For instance, the fact that two liters of hydrogen will react with just one liter of oxygen to produce two liters of water vapor suggested that a single oxygen molecule splits in two in order to form two molecules of water. This give the correct formula of water, H2O, not HO. Avogadro measured oxygen's atomic weight to be 15.074.
Opposition to atomic theory
Dalton's atomic theory attracted widespread interest but not universal acceptance.One problem was the lack of uniform nomenclature. The word "atom" implied indivisibility, but Dalton defined an atom as being the ultimate particle of any chemical substance, not just the elements or even matter per se. This meant that "compound atoms" such as carbon dioxide could be divided, as opposed to "elementary atoms". Dalton disliked the word "molecule", regarding it as "diminutive". Amedeo Avogadro did the opposite: he exclusively used the word "molecule" in his writings, eschewing the word "atom", instead using the term "elementary molecule". Jöns Jacob Berzelius used the term "organic atoms" to refer to particles containing three or more elements, because he thought this only existed in organic compounds. Jean-Baptiste Dumas used the terms "physical atoms" and "chemical atoms"; a "physical atom" was a particle that cannot be divided by physical means such as temperature and pressure, and a "chemical atom" was a particle that could not be divided by chemical reactions.
The modern definitions of atom and molecule—an atom being the basic particle of an element, and a molecule being an agglomeration of atoms—were established in the latter half of the 19th century. A key event was the Karlsruhe Congress in Germany in 1860. As the first international congress of chemists, its goal was to establish some standards in the community. A major proponent of the modern distinction between atoms and molecules was Stanislao Cannizzaro.
A second objection to atomic theory was philosophical. Scientists in the 19th century had no way of directly observing atoms. They inferred the existence of atoms through indirect observations, such as Dalton's law of multiple proportions. Some scientists adopted positions aligned with the philosophy of positivism, arguing that scientists should not attempt to deduce the deeper reality of the universe, but only systemize what patterns they could directly observe.
This generation of anti-atomists can be grouped in two camps.
The "equivalentists", like Marcellin Berthelot, believed the theory of equivalent weights was adequate for scientific purposes. This generalization of Proust's law of definite proportions summarized observations. For example, 1 gram of hydrogen will combine with 8 grams of oxygen to form 9 grams of water, therefore the "equivalent weight" of oxygen is 8 grams. These ideas where widely used by chemists without accepting an underlying atomic explanation. The "energeticist", like Ernst Mach and Wilhelm Ostwald, were philosophically opposed to hypothesis about reality altogether. In their view, only energy as part of thermodynamics should be the basis of physical models.
These positions were eventually quashed by two important advancements that happened later in the 19th century: the development of the periodic table and the discovery that molecules have an internal architecture that determines their properties.