Columbus Buckeyes all-time roster
The Columbus Buckeyes were a professional baseball team that played in the American Association for two seasons from 1883 to 1884. The franchise used Recreation Park I as their home field. During their two seasons of existence, the team had a record of 101–104.
Players
| Player | Position | Season | Notes | Ref |
| Pitcher | 1884 | |||
| Right fielder | 1883–1884 | Brown led the Buckeyes in runs scored in 1884. | ||
| Left fielder | 1884 | |||
| Catcher | 1884 | Carroll led the Buckeyes in batting average in 1884. | ||
| First baseman | 1883 | |||
| Pitcher | 1883–1884 | |||
| First baseman | 1883–1884 | |||
| Pitcher | 1883 | |||
| Catcher | 1883–1884 | |||
| Third baseman | 1883–1884 | |||
| Center fielder | 1883–1884 | |||
| Left fielder | 1884 | |||
| Pitcher | 1883 | |||
| Pitcher | 1884 | Morris led the Buckeyes in wins and strikeouts in 1884. | ||
| Pitcher | 1883–1884 | Mountain led the Buckeyes in wins and strikeouts in 1883. | ||
| Second baseman | 1883 | |||
| Shortstop | 1883–1884 | Richmond led the Buckeyes in batting average in 1883. | ||
| Catcher / First baseman | 1883 | |||
| Second baseman | 1883–1884 | Smith led the Buckeyes in runs scored in 1883. | ||
| Catcher | 1883 | |||
| Pitcher | 1884 | |||
| Pitcher | 1883 | |||
| Left fielder | 1883 |